We’re talking pennies on the dollar, but …
In October, Illinois Attorney General Kwame Raoul joined counterparts from 19 other states and the Federal Trade Commission to sue Dollar General for “regularly and repeatedly charging shoppers more at the register than the prices it advertises,” he said in a release.
A hint at how that might play out in court dropped Friday in a different statement announcing a “$63 million national settlement with Family Dollar stores in price transparency win for consumers.”
That action, involving the FTC and 16 states, rests on similar allegations: thousands of stores nationwide overcharged for items; shelf labels differ from what the register scans or prices published online are lower than what customers pay in stores. The coalition said Family Dollar didn’t correct problems “despite thousands of failed inspections, hundreds of consumer complaints and multiple enforcement actions.”
Family Dollar said it will create “a $40 million consumer redress fund payable to eligible consumers” who bought something from Jan. 1, 2023, through Oct. 1, 2026, “and a $20 million discount program,” essentially a mandatory two-day 15% off sale for everything aside from alcohol, tobacco and gift cards. The other $3 million will go to the states – Illinois will get $188,548.
The court filing doesn’t indicate how many customers might qualify for the redress fund, but Family Dollar operates more than 7,000 stores in the country, so about $5,715 per location. Even factoring in the other $23 million, it’d be easy to mount the familiar argument that this sort of financial penalty is ultimately just the cost of doing business for a company spun off for more than $1 billion in 2025.
But getting back to those pennies on the dollar: What are the sales tax implications?
Family Dollar is advertising an artificial Christmas tree for $35. At that price, I’d pay more than $3 in sales tax, the bulk of it to the state (at 6.25%, so $2.19). But if the store charged me $40, the state’s portion would be $2.50, up 31 cents.
Not everything Family Dollar sells qualifies for the full retail tax, and I don’t actually know the gaps between what the store advertised versus what customers paid. But the principle is easily explained: the more a store charges a customer, the more pennies that transaction generates in sales tax. Those incremental increases don’t appear headed back to consumers.
To the extent any customer gets financial relief, they’re unlikely to care about the source. But don’t hold your breath waiting for the Illinois Department of Revenue to calculate how much tax revenue comes from point-of-sale error, be that honest mistakes or provable chicanery.
At some point, all those pennies add up to meaningful money.
• Scott T. Holland writes about state government issues for Shaw Local News Network. He can be reached at sholland@shawmedia.com.
Top Feeds,Politics
via Shaw Media Local https://ift.tt/hFXE9rG
November 18, 2026 at 10:05AM
