Illinois Republicans turn on each other after election rout but few leaders pointing to Trump as a problem

https://ift.tt/SY7j2xo

Following the 2010 midterm elections, Illinois Republicans saw a renaissance.

They won a U.S. Senate seat and two statewide offices in comptroller and treasurer, flipped four congressional seats from blue to red to take control of the Washington delegation, and gained six Illinois House seats and two state Senate seats to end Democratic supermajorities in the legislature.

Now, after Nov. 3’s blue wave, Illinois Republicans saw their candidates blown out in every statewide race, their 14-3 congressional minority secured, and Democratic state legislative supermajorities expanded to record levels not seen since single-member legislative districts were imposed in 1983.

After the election scorecard was revealed, the resulting backlash was almost predictable. An Illinois GOP that had been a credible force little more than a decade ago saw its factions form a circular firing squad, looking to attach blame to various leaders while failing to address the real reason behind their losses.

Euphemisms such as the “nationalization” of local elections were often cited. But after their invective, few people named the real reason: a backlash against the party’s national leader, President Donald Trump.

“This was a rejection of Donald Trump that went as far as hell,” said Pat Brady, who served as state GOP chair during those heady days early in the 2010s. “What are you going to do when you’ve got a gale-force national headwind, a (Democratic) party with a lot of money who very effectively nationalized the election? It was a recipe for disaster.

”I said it 11 years ago: ‘Donald Trump will be a disaster for Illinois Republicans,’ and that was spot on. His national brand has destroyed the Illinois Republican Party. Other things have happened, too. I get that. But he absolutely crushed us,” Brady said.

Voter pushback against Trump was extensive. Democratic Gov. JB Pritzker secured a third term and advanced his potential 2028 White House bid by toppling GOP challenger Darren Bailey, nearly doubling the margin by which he had beaten Bailey four years ago. While final votes in a few races are still being tallied, the Democratic supermajority in the Illinois House grew from 78-40 to as much as 84-34, and in the Illinois Senate from 40-19 to 45-14.

The repudiation of Trump in Illinois was so resounding that McHenry County — the last Republican stronghold among the collar counties — voted for Pritzker. It was the first time since 1852 that the county backed a Democrat for governor.

The seeds of the Illinois GOP’s dismantling were planted not long into Brady’s tenure as party chair, the result of a Democratic trifecta: a Democratic governor and control of the state House and Senate.

Democratic redistricting erased the 2010 Republican gains in the congressional and legislative delegations. Brady was ousted as chair in 2013 after he personally supported same-sex marriage. That put him at odds with the state GOP platform, which still dictates that marriage should be between “one man and one woman.”

Republicans also failed to adjust to changing demographics in the suburbs — including empowered socially moderate women and an influx of racially and ethnically diverse voters — a region that had once served as the party base and a firewall against Democratic turnout in Chicago.

Five people have led the state party in the 13 years since Brady stepped down. Republican Bruce Rauner was elected governor in 2014, the last time a Republican won a statewide race. But his single term was marked by ineptitude and a staunch anti-union stance that led to the state being without a budget for two years.

In the meantime, far-right conservatives gained control of the state party apparatus and tied the GOP ideology and brand firmly to Trumpism in sharp contrast to the beliefs and values of most voters in the Chicago area, the state’s most populated region.

Pushing the party’s rightward movement were those looking to gain public recognition or financial benefit by lobbing attacks rather than delivering electoral results.

There is political operative Dan Proft, a right-wing radio host who lives in Florida, who has channeled millions of dollars from ultraconservative megadonor Richard Uihlein into failed campaigns.

There is Tom DeVore, a downstate attorney and failed 2022 GOP attorney general candidate who had his law license suspended for six months over having a sexual relationship with a client, who trolls Republican leadership on social media.

There is Mark Vargas, who is close to the Trump inner circle and a conservative website publisher, who helped disgraced former Democratic Gov. Rod Blagojevich win a Trump commutation and pardon of his federal prison sentence on corruption charges.

Vargas posted a video of himself on social media calling for the ouster of Illinois House GOP leader Tony McCombie of Savanna, saying she hadn’t done enough to protect House seats from the Democratic onslaught but not offering a reason for the election result. Vargas, who made his remarks while wearing a blue sweater embroidered with “TRUMP,” has regularly criticized state party members for not doing more to embrace the president.

DeVore, who has the words “Freedom” and “Liberty” tattooed on his forearms, also took to social media to call for the ouster of McCombie and Illinois Senate GOP leader John Curran of Downers Grove when members vote on Republican legislative leadership this week as lawmakers reconvene in Springfield for the fall veto session.

Then-GOP attorney general candidate Tom DeVore appears at a "Make Illinois Great" rally at the Kane County Fairgrounds on Sept. 11, 2022.(Brian O'Mahoney for the Chicago Tribune)
Then-GOP attorney general candidate Tom DeVore appears at a “Make Illinois Great” rally at the Kane County Fairgrounds on Sept. 11, 2022.(Brian O’Mahoney for the Chicago Tribune)

DeVore warned if Republican lawmakers fail to oust the pair, “I am going to find out how every one of you voted, and when your primary comes around I am going to put tens of thousands of text messages into your district with your name on them.”

“In my opinion, they’re Dem operatives. They’re portraying themselves as Republicans. But they’re about anything to hurt Republicans and this is all clickbait,” McCombie said of Vargas and DeVore. “It doesn’t matter. Whoever is in leadership is going to be the victim of their attacks.”

There is also Jeanne Ives, a former GOP state lawmaker from Wheaton and a Proft ally who ran unsuccessfully for governor and Congress. A West Point graduate who touts the school motto that “a cadet will not lie, cheat, steal, or tolerate those who do,” Ives is nevertheless an ardent supporter of Trump.

Former state Rep. Jeanne Ives speaks as parents protest against mask mandates in schools on Feb. 7, 2022, outside the District 181 Administration Center in Clarendon Hills. (Brian Cassella/Chicago Tribune)
Former state Rep. Jeanne Ives speaks as parents protest against mask mandates in schools on Feb. 7, 2022, outside the District 181 Administration Center in Clarendon Hills. (Brian Cassella/Chicago Tribune)

Ives said in her weekly email newsletter that she viewed the Democratic victories as the result of “three things,” though she listed five. Among them were a “visceral hate” for Trump, which she said was fueled by his “relentless demonization” in legacy media, “tribal voting,” which she said was manifested by “their ethnic groups: Muslims, Indians, Latinos,” and her belief that voters were stupid.

“Dumbing down of American voters through social media and poor K-12 and Woke undergraduate education,” she wrote.

McCombie partly blamed the White House for not showcasing “the good things that have come out of the administration,” such as rising retirement investment portfolios. Instead, she said, the focus was on “things that aren’t serious,” such as “the Gulf of America or (seizing) Greenland,” and the now-canceled plan to livestream the firing-squad execution of Nidal Malik Hasan, the former Army psychiatrist convicted of the 2009 Fort Hood mass shooting.

“We should be talking about affordability and gas prices and maybe thoroughly explaining more to the people about Iran,” she said, referring to Trump’s war in the Middle East that has resulted in higher consumer prices, particularly for gas.

“To me, the election showed that people want serious, commonsense legislators on a county level, a state level, a federal level, and they don’t feel they have that,” said McCombie, who appears headed for reelection as House GOP leader, as does Curran in the state Senate.

“I don’t know even if I could have gotten three more million dollars, five more million dollars, I don’t know that would have made a difference this cycle,” she said. “It is the national trend. There’s no ifs, ands, or buts about it, and I can’t control those. … I think (the GOP losses) ultimately just was that they had an R behind their name.”

Aaron Del Mar enters the room and says "we will not concede until every vote is counted," at the election night watch party for Republican gubernatorial candidate Darren Bailey and running mate Del Mar at the Effingham Holiday Inn on Nov. 3, 2026. (Tim Vizer/for the Chicago Tribune)
Aaron Del Mar enters the room and says “we will not concede until every vote is counted,” at the election night watch party for Republican gubernatorial candidate Darren Bailey and running mate Del Mar at the Effingham Holiday Inn on Nov. 3, 2026. (Tim Vizer/for the Chicago Tribune)

Aaron Del Mar, Bailey’s running mate and a member of the current GOP state central committee, has proposed a total reset for the Illinois GOP. It would start with a state convention in March to write new bylaws and a party platform.

Del Mar also wants voters to directly elect the state central committee, an idea that has been debated for decades. He also wants state central committee members to represent geographical boundaries separate from congressional districts currently drawn by Democrats, and a year-round candidate recruitment process.

“We need to clearly define what the Illinois Republican Party stands for, not what we’re just against. Lower costs, safer streets, better schools, more jobs, responsible spending and zero tolerance for corruption,” Del Mar said. “Illinois doesn’t need another Republican power struggle. It needs a Republican Party capable of being an opposition party.”

Bob Grogan, the former DuPage County auditor who was elected state GOP chair on May 18, acknowledged that he thought Illinois Republicans had hit “bedrock” after the election results but said he didn’t think blowing up the organization was necessary.

Citing the selection of newcomers making up a vast majority of the state central committee earlier this year, Grogan said, “I would very easily argue that you have a fresh leadership team at the state party.”

Grogan said losses were to be expected in presidential midterm elections and historically, after six years, “there gets to be fatigue of the person that’s in the White House,” Republican or Democrat.

“Obviously, that’s a reflection on the president. And you know, after six years, people … start to wear thin, and they express that,” he said of the election results.

But he also said Trump “was out there doing everything he could” to campaign on behalf of Republicans across country. Grogan didn’t mention the president’s economic, tariff and war strategies that voters felt in their pocketbooks or off-message comments, such as one in June when Trump said, “I love the inflation.”

The state GOP’s decline in what was once its suburban base, Grogan said, “was a long-term trend that started before Trump was even on the scene.”

“There’s long-term demographic issues that we’re going to be dealing with, and we have to start communicating what I think are majority policy positions in a language that suburban voters understand and that’s probably what we haven’t been doing,” he said.

To reverse the party’s fortunes in Illinois, Grogan is looking to an open-seat presidential contest in 2028 after Democrats control Congress.

“I think that will bring a lot of excitement out. I actually think that the Republicans’ stances on a lot of core issues actually are very popular, and the Democrats, I think, are going to overinterpret their wins here as an endorsement of every crazy idea their sociology professor had in college,” he said.

But counting on Democratic miscues in Congress and a presidential campaign to resurrect the state GOP fails to address the party’s inability to modernize and change along with the suburban demographics.

One example came at Del Mar’s post-election news conference, where he made his call for the GOP to start from scratch.

Introducing him was Kristina McCloy, a suburban DuPage woman who leads the Concerned Parents of Illinois, a group with a history of disputes over book bans, school curriculum, anti-LGBTQ+ activities and racially charged rhetoric involving Islamophobia and alleging incidents of Black children attacking white children at school were underreported without offering any proof.

“If that’s what party leadership wants to keep talking about,” Brady said of McCloy’s involvement in a remade state GOP, “you just kiss the whole thing goodbye because you’re never going to raise a nickel.”

Top Feeds

via Chicago Tribune https://ift.tt/GfSMEgA

November 16, 2026 at 05:21AM

Leave a Reply